I get this one a lot from different ammunition customers, as well as those looking for the consummate rifle to do it all. The 30-06 has a more aerodynamic spitzer bullet so will be more accurate and more effective at greater distances than the round nosed 45-70. 270 vs 30-06 Caliber comparison. "The new cartridge was a replacement for the stop-gap .50-70 Government cartridge, which had been adopted in 1866, one year after the end of the American Civil War or any of the newer or more exotic mags out there in .30 caliber. 5 Comments on 308 vs 30-06; This article is written with beginning hunters in mind as they choose their hunting rifle and are considering the differences between the 308 Winchester and 30-06 Springfield. Although At first glance, it is clear that the 7mm Rem Mag rounds have higher BCs than the .30-06 rounds with several of the rounds breaking the .6 mark. I had the 45-70 Marlin, and the cool wore off for me after about a dozen rounds. I replaced it with a 416 Ruger. HOWEVER, the muzzle energy of the 45-70 is higher so if you shoot something close up, the 45-70 is better. Ammo Price and Availability. The 45-70 is a good bear gun. Please note, the following information reflects the estimated average ballistics for each caliber and does not pertain to a particular manufacturer, bullet weight, or jacketing type. Different rifles seldom produce identical performance, even with … By that yardstick it is hard to fault a .300 Win. :eek: Mag. Nearly ballistic twins, the .308 versus .30-06 debate seems moot. I've shot 308's, 30-06's, 45-70's, and 30-30's. By Chuck Hawks. 30-06 vs. 30-30, two tried-and-true rifle cartridges are commonly found in the field. How Does The .308 Vs .30-06 Debate Shake Out: Given its larger case capacity, the .30-06 can be pushed to moderately higher velocities. These are not high-volume rifle cartridges; it’s unlikely that you’ll fire off close to a thousand rounds in a single afternoon, the way you might with a semi-automatic rifle discharging .223 Remington cartridges, for example. Trying to decide between the 308 vs 30-06 round for hunting? The nice thing about the 45-70 and .444 is that when you shoot something, it's down right there. Ballistics, velocity, trajectory, and energy data analysis. 308 left, 30-06 right What’s great about both the 308 and 30-06. May 21, 2020 By Brad Fitzpatrick. I have been considering a 30/06 in a similar length. 45-70 is great in a heavy gun, but in that light Marlin Guide gun, it will hammer you. Even the .444’s parent offers only … In order to hit a distant target a rifle must be correctly sighted-in, and to accomplish that the shooter must have some working knowledge of the bullet's trajectory. If you have gone past the challenges faced by most modern shooters, you shoot a .45-70 round at a further range than the .30-30. In this Remington Magnum 7mm vs 30-06 Springfield review, we explore the different features of both rifles to figure out which one is best for you. Have a look at .308 Win vs 30-06 Springfield and points out the differences between the two. 45/70 is a massive mammerjammer. How would these compare in … The .45-70 is also handicapped by the fact that a lot of the factory ammo out there doesn’t take the cartridge to its fullest—due to the wide range of rifles old and new, as well as action type. Extensive information about rifle cartridge trajectory. This is illustrated in the table below comparing a two different .45-70 Govt loads to a pretty typical .30-06 load. But at least you can find a variety of .45-70 rifles. Graphs and visuals can be filtered and changed by you. The 270 Win only ranges from 100 gr to 150 gr (range of 50). One .45-70 load approximates the performance of the original .45-70 Govt black powder loading of a 405 grain bullet (.307 BC) at 1350 feet per second while the other is a 325gr Hornady LEVERevolution factory load (.230 BC). Re: accuracy at range .45/70 vs .30/06 « Reply #3 on: October 06, 2009, 02:21:13 PM » You cant compare these two rounds, they are made for different duty. a shade more than a .338 Win Mag. 45-70 vs. 30-30 Price Comparison 30-30 Win ammo on the left compared to 45-70 Govt ammunition on the right. The .45-70 Government is definitely the older of the two, having been released in 1873 in the famous Trapdoor Springfield. The two have more similarities than differences. However for the tasks you have described the 30-30 would suffice just fine. I have a 12 inch 45/70 with no break. The following ammunition cartridge ballistics information and chart can be used to approximately compare .30-30 Winchester vs .45-70 Government ammo rounds. .45-70 vs. .30-30 Ballistic Comparisons Both cartridges show similar performances in terms of ballistics, displaying a range of around 300 yards. Let me walk you through a non-biased 308 vs. 30-06 review. It will easily take all of but the largest North American game. Must see data comparison! This velocity gives is a slight edge at longer ranges. That is pretty sharp recoil, about double the recoil of a .30-06 with 150 gr bullets. 45/70 is a big close in bear killer, the 06 has a very diverse amount of bullet chamberings from small to large. The 32 WS hits harder than the old 30 WCF and I think has better terminal velocity than the .35 Remington. This showdown, 30 06 vs. 308, will be hard to call! The 270 vs 30-06 debate has gone on for about as long as the .270 Winchester and .30-06 Springfield have existed. 30-06 vs 270 Ammo Variances. Also, the .30-06 is a parent cartridge of the .308. By Chuck Hawks. 45-70 is mainly in lever guns and the 06 in bolt. A plus for the 30-30 is ammo is usually plentiful and not overly expensive. As for me, I'd look at the Rem 700s or Winchester 70s as both are good solid rifles that will last you a lifetime. The recoil is noticeable,to say the least. First of all, the two cartridges share a lot of history. There are dozens of loads for any given bullet weight in any cartridge that will produce different velocity and energy figures. Guns - 45-70 vs 30.06 - Due to the fact that most hunts will be on elk and smaller animals, I vote for the 30-06 due to its range advantage. I've never killed a grizzly but I would be very comfortable using a .30-06 loaded with 180-grain bullets on one. I have a couple of 45-70 rifles. Finding the best .30-06 rifle is relatively easy as the gun has a pretty strict set of parameters it operates under. The .45-70 rifle cartridge, also known as .45-70 Government, was developed at the U.S. Army's Springfield Armory for use in the Springfield Model 1873, which is known to collectors as the "Trapdoor Springfield. According to Chuck Hawk's Rifle recoil Tables, a .45-70 with 350 gr bullets at 1,900 fps produces 37.9 ft lbs of recoil in a 7 pound rifle. 30-30 or 32 Winchester Special. Where as … The Marlin is too light, which is part of it's appeal, but doesn't help for recoil. Advantage in bolt gun is easier to get an accurate gun with a good trigger. If the primary goal is target shooting and the minor role is hunting, I'd choose a bolt action in .308. The .30-06 was first introduced in 1906 with the Springfield 1903 bolt action rifle; since then, it has won the hearts of many and managed to remain one of the most popular rifle cartridges in the world, even today. You can find 30-06 ammo in 130 grain all the way to 220 grain (range of 90). The 30-06 wins here. The '06 is a good everything gun. But on the othrhand neither one is for the recoil shy. I know plenty of guys who hunt deer and hogs around here with a 45-70, simply because the ranges are under 150yds (mostly under 75yds) and it drops them like a fucking rock, but doesn't damage the meat as much. As for the 45-70, well there is a definite cool factor to take into consideration. Hunters who travel a lot reach to find that one "do it all" round that is big enough for heavy game and will shoot flat for longer shots they might encounter. The 30.06 has a much better range than the 45-70. If I was only going to have one rifle it would be '06. By the numbers, according to the Chuck Hawks recoil table, an 8-lb. The .30-06 is one of the most versatile large rifle cartridges on the planet (it’s technically not a “large” rifle cartridge) – we will touch on that later. Rich Ah, boy. However, some nuances can swing hunters and shooters one way or another. I’d have thought that by now—some 56 years after the introduction of the .308 Winchester as a sporting round—the feud would have settled down, but it certainly doesn’t look that way. At distance the 45-70 drops off quite a bit in power due to its rounded bullet. I personally like the .450 much better than the 45-70, but also have come to dread pulling the trigger! Both are great, but you should hunt with .45-70 vs .450 Bushmaster — Cartridge Clash This cartridge clash between the .45-70 Gov't and .450 Bushmaster is less about the minute details of the cartridge and more about your personal taste in firearms. Let's examine these two calibers and see the pros and cons of each as well as … Most people attest that .270 vs .30-06 favors the lighter round. rifle in .270 generates 16.5 ft-lbs of recoil with a 130-grain load at 3,140 fps. For the 7mm Rem Mag vs .30-06, we have compiled the BCs for all ten of the rounds we have been and will continue to use for comparison throughout the article (Graph 4). I'm not saying it is not manageable, just the facts. The 308 Winchester was birthed by the 30-06 back in 1952. A rifle of the same weight in .30-06 generates 20.1 ft … The U.S. Army adopted the new cartridge, which replaced the .50-70 cartridge it employed in 1866. The .45-70 lever action has much more cool factor, but for a big bore working rifle, there are better choices. I shoot a lot of Magnum rounds as well as .308 and 30/06 and My 45-70 has more of a heavy Push type recoil vs. a shoulder slamming punch. Even putting that aside, a quick look at the Hodgdon reloading manual shows that if you load a 300 grain bullet, which is about as heavy as the .450 goes, and about as light as the .45-70 goes, that even the Trapdoor level loads that are safe for the original black powder Springfield rifles are about neck and neck with 450 Bushmaster, with a slight edge to the .45-70. Good recoil Pads or a shooting jacket with a shoulder pad can help minimize felt recoil. I’ve owned and shot some eight .45–70s over the years, from trapdoor Springfields, Remington rolling blocks, break H&Rs, Marlin lever action, and a #3 Ruger. Back in 1936, the M1 Garand was chosen as the standard U.S. Military issue rifle. The 30-06 has a much larger range of bullet weights than the .270 Win. Two of the most well-known cartridges go head-to-head in this detailed article.